Replacement Broadcast Towers from WTC may be World's Tallest Structure on Governor's Island
May 2, 2002
NEWARK, N.J. (AP) -- Broadcasters who lost transmission facilities when the World Trade Center collapsed are eyeing Jersey City or Governors Island in New York as the site of a 2,000-foot-tall tower that would be the world's tallest free-standing structure.
The two sites are being proposed for the hour-glass-shaped toward because it would have to be located no more than 3.2 miles from the former trade center site in order to avoid interfering with broadcasting in other nearby cities.
"It's a very beautiful form that could be a great asset to the entire New York area," said A. Eugene Kohn, one of a team of four architects who drew up plans for the tower. "It could be a symbolic replacement for the World Trade towers on the New York skyline, which are sorely missed."
His firm, Kohn Pedersen Fox, was hired by the Metropolitan TV Alliance, a trade group representing 10 New York-area stations. The broadcasters urgently need new transmission facilities to replace the antenna that fell when the trade center's north tower collapsed.
"They must have a tower to have a telecast," said Phil Roberts, executive director of the New Jersey Broadcasters Association. "It has put high-definition TV on the back burner because they don't have the tower. And aside from high-definition TV, they're having trouble broadcasting regular TV right now."
Broadcasters have temporarily relocated their antennas to the Empire State Building. But that location isn't high enough and doesn't allow for a signal strong enough to reach the entire metropolitan region.
The broadcasters also estimate that 350,000 homes in New York City still have no reception or an unclear signal.
William Baker, president and CEO of WNET, who heads the TV Alliance, did not immediately return a telephone call seeking comment on the plan Thursday.
Architects envision an open-air concrete and steel tower encircled by crisscrossing 10-inch steel cables. The project could cost between $150 million and $200 million, but part of the cost would be offset by locating a restaurant and observation deck at about 1,300 feet and retail shops around the base.
Kohn said the tower could become a tourist attraction similar to the 1,815-foot-tall CN Tower in Toronto, which is the tallest free-standing structure in the world. Most of that tower is hollow, but the base and top include observation decks, restaurants, retail shops, an arcade and a movie theater.
The world's tallest occupied building is the Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, at 1,483 feet. The World Trade Center's roofs were 1,360 feet above ground level, and the antenna on the north tower reached to 1,728 feet.
Kohn said he doesn't think the tower would become a tempting target for terrorists because it would not have nearly as many occupants as a large office building.
"Everyone's sensitive about building anything tall right now, but if you think about it, in addition to destroying a symbol, the terrorists also wanted to kill a lot of people and do a lot of damage," he said.
Jersey City officials said they support the concept of the tower, but want to hear more details.
The project would require numerous layers of approvals. In addition to local zoning and planning reviews, the state Department of Environmental Protection would have to evaluate it, and the Federal Aviation Administration would have to review the plans to make sure the tower does not interfere with flights in and out of the region.
Al Ivany, a DEP spokesman, said no plans have yet been filed with the state. Kohn said he did not know when formal applications might be ready for submission.
Roberts predicted the Governors Island site might ultimately be judged more feasible than Jersey City.
"The not-in-my-backyard factor will dictate that it can't be where anybody lives," he said. "Think of where there wouldn't be that problem: on an island in the middle of a river."
Archive#1
Archive#2
Archive#3
Archive#4
Archive#5
Archive#6
Archive#7
Archive#8
Archive#9
Archive#10
Archive#11
Archive#12
Archive#13
Archive#14
Archive#15
Archive#16
Archive#17
Archive#18